Back to blog
Building HR

A Simple Performance Review System for Growing Companies

A light performance review system for companies of 20 to 150 people in Egypt and Saudi Arabia: goals, monthly one-to-ones, quarterly check-ins, a fair rating scale and how to handle poor performance.

By Mohamed ShaheenNovember 18, 20268 min read

Most growing companies swing between two extremes. Either there is no performance process at all, and people find out what their manager thinks only when they ask for a raise. Or someone copies a 12-page form from a large corporate, managers fill it in once a year, and nobody reads it again.

Neither works. What a company of 20 to 150 people needs is a light system that managers will actually use. This guide gives you one you can set up in a month.

Why the annual review alone fails

Gallup found that only 14% of employees strongly agree that their performance reviews inspire them to improve. Gallup also reports that only about half of employees clearly know what is expected of them at work.

The problem is not the form. It is that expectations are unclear, feedback comes too late, and one meeting is asked to do everything: judge the past year, plan development and decide pay. A simple system fixes those three things.

The system on one page

PartHow oftenWhat happens
GoalsSet each quarter or half-yearThree to five clear goals per person, agreed with the manager
One-to-oneMonthly, 30 minutesProgress, blockers and support, led by three simple questions
Quarterly check-inEvery three monthsShort written review of goals and behaviours, goals reset if needed
Annual reviewOnce a yearSummary of the four check-ins and a rating, with no surprises
Pay conversationOnce a year, separate meetingRaise or bonus, based on the rating and the budget

Step 1: set clear goals

Each person needs three to five goals for the quarter or half-year. A good goal says what will be different, by when, and how you will know. "Improve recruitment" is not a goal. "Cut time-to-hire for sales roles from 45 to 30 days by June" is.

Add your company values or four to five key behaviours, such as ownership, teamwork and customer focus. People should be reviewed on what they deliver and how they deliver it.

Step 2: hold monthly one-to-ones

This is where performance is really managed. Thirty minutes a month is enough if the manager asks three questions:

  • What went well since we last met?
  • What is getting in your way?
  • What do you need from me?

The manager writes two or three lines after each meeting. Those notes make the quarterly check-in easy and, if it is ever needed, they are the record of what was discussed.

Step 3: run a short quarterly check-in

Every three months, the employee and the manager each fill in a one-page form, then meet for 45 minutes. Keep the form short:

  • Progress on each goal: done, on track or off track, with one line of evidence.
  • Behaviours: one example of each value shown well, and one area to improve.
  • Development: one skill to build next quarter and how.
  • Next quarter: confirm or reset the goals.

Step 4: use a simple rating scale

A five-point scale invites everyone to choose the middle. For a growing company, three clear levels are enough:

RatingMeaningTypical outcome
ExceedsDelivered beyond the goals and showed the values stronglyHigher raise or bonus, promotion discussion
MeetsDelivered the goals and showed the valuesStandard raise
BelowMissed key goals or showed behaviour problemsSupport plan, no merit raise this cycle

Use "too new to rate" for anyone who joined in the last three months. Before ratings are shared, hold a one-hour calibration meeting where managers compare their ratings, so "Exceeds" means the same thing in every team.

Step 5: keep pay in a separate meeting

When pay and feedback are discussed together, people only hear the number. Gallup recommends separating the two conversations. Hold the annual review first, then a short pay meeting a week or two later. Link raises to the rating with a simple table agreed in advance, so managers apply the same rules.

When performance is not good enough

A simple system should make poor performance visible early, and give the person a fair chance to improve. Use this path:

  1. Raise it early, in a one-to-one, with specific examples. Note it the same day.
  2. If it continues, hold a documented meeting and agree what must change.
  3. Put a written improvement plan in place for 30 to 90 days, with clear targets, the support you will give and review dates.
  4. Review progress on the agreed dates and record the outcome.
  5. If there is still no improvement, take advice before any decision about the contract.

The legal side in Egypt and Saudi Arabia

  • Egypt: under Labour Law No. 14 of 2025, inefficiency can be a lawful ground for ending a contract, but only after following internal procedures. Dismissal as a disciplinary penalty needs a labour court ruling, and ending an indefinite contract without a legitimate reason means compensation of at least two months' wage per year of service.
  • Saudi Arabia: if a contract is ended without a valid reason, the employee can claim compensation under Article 77. For an indefinite contract this is 15 days' wage per year of service, with a minimum of two months' wage.
  • In both countries, your one-to-one notes, check-in forms, warnings and improvement plan are the evidence. Without them, a performance-based exit is very hard to defend.
  • Use probation properly: up to 180 days in Saudi Arabia if agreed in the contract, and up to three months in Egypt, applied only once. Decide before it ends.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Copying a long corporate form that managers will not complete.
  • Saving all feedback for the end of the year.
  • Rating everyone "Meets" to avoid difficult conversations.
  • Linking every point of the rating directly to pay, so people argue about the score instead of the work.
  • Launching the system without training managers on how to give feedback.

Your first year

  • Month 1: agree the values, write the one-page forms and train managers in a two-hour session.
  • Months 1 to 3: set goals for everyone and start monthly one-to-ones.
  • Month 3: first quarterly check-in. Ask managers and employees what to simplify.
  • Months 6 and 9: second and third check-ins.
  • Month 12: annual review, calibration meeting and separate pay conversations.

A spreadsheet and a shared form are enough to start. Move to an HR system once the process works. For where this fits in the bigger picture, read How to Build an HR Function in Your First 100 Employees. For the legal detail, see Egypt's New Labour Law checklist or Your First 10 HR Policies for Saudi Arabia.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a review form be?

One page for the quarterly check-in and no more than two for the annual review. If a manager needs more than 30 minutes to fill it in, it is too long.

Should we use 360-degree feedback?

Not at the start. Get goals and monthly one-to-ones working first. Add short peer feedback for managers once the basics are in place.

Can we skip ratings altogether?

You can, but most growing companies need some way to decide raises and promotions fairly. Three clear levels with a calibration meeting are a good middle ground.

Simple, regular and fair

A good performance system is not the one with the best form. It is the one where people know what is expected, hear how they are doing every month and are never surprised at the end of the year.

If you would like help setting goals, designing your forms or training your managers, you can work with me directly.

Note: This article is general guidance and not legal advice. Before ending any contract for performance reasons, take advice on your specific case.

Last updated: 18 November 2026

References

Share

Keep reading