Running a Fair Hiring Interview: Competency-Based Questions and the STAR Technique
Run fair, structured interviews: competency-based questions, the STAR technique and how to link them, a worked example, and questions to avoid in Egypt and Saudi Arabia.
Most interviews are friendly conversations. The manager asks whatever comes to mind, likes the candidate who reminds them of themselves, and decides on a feeling. Then the person who interviewed best turns out not to be the person who performs best.
A structured interview fixes that. It is fairer to candidates, easier for managers, and far better at predicting who will do the job well. This guide shows how to run one with competency-based questions and the STAR technique, how to link the two, which questions to avoid under the law in Egypt and Saudi Arabia, and how to handle candidate data.
Why structure matters
In 2022, Paul Sackett and colleagues re-examined decades of research on hiring methods. Structured interviews came out as the top-ranked selection method for predicting job performance, with more than double the predictive power of unstructured interviews. The same research found that structured interviews also showed less bias. In short, asking every candidate the same job-related questions and scoring them the same way works better than a free conversation.
The five elements of a structured interview
1. Start from the job
Take the outcomes and competencies from the job description. Pick the four to six that matter most; these are what you will assess. If your job description does not have them yet, start with Job Descriptions That Attract the Right People.
2. Ask every candidate the same core questions
Write two questions for each competency before the first interview. You can ask follow-ups, but every candidate gets the same core set, so you are comparing like with like.
3. Agree the scoring scale in advance
Use a simple 1 to 5 scale and describe what a 1, a 3 and a 5 look like for each competency. Without that, one interviewer's 4 is another's 2.
4. Score independently, then discuss
Each interviewer scores on their own, straight after the interview, before talking to anyone else. Then the panel compares scores and discusses the gaps. This stops the most senior or loudest person deciding for everyone.
5. Record the evidence and the reason
Write down what the candidate said and did, not your impression of them. Record the final decision and the reason in a sentence or two. Our Interview Scorecard has space for all of this.
Three types of question that work
| Type | What it tests | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Behavioural | What the person has actually done | "Tell me about a time you had to deliver results with a team that did not report to you. What did you do, and what happened?" |
| Situational | How they would handle a likely scenario in this role | "In your second week, two managers ask you for urgent work due the same day. What do you do?" |
| Work sample | The actual skill, in a short realistic task | A 30-minute exercise: draft a job ad from a short brief, or review a sample report and list the problems |
Competency-based interviewing and the STAR technique
A competency-based interview is the heart of a structured interview. Each question targets one competency from the job description and asks for evidence of how the candidate has actually behaved. The idea is simple: how someone handled similar situations in the past is the best guide to how they will handle them in your company.
The STAR technique is how you collect and judge that evidence. It breaks a complete answer into four parts:
| Part | What you want to hear | Probe if it is missing | Warning signs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Situation | A specific, real example: when, where and who was involved | "When was this? What was the context?" | General statements such as "I always..." or "we usually..." |
| Task | What the candidate personally had to achieve, and why it mattered | "What exactly was your responsibility?" | Only the team's goal, with no personal role |
| Action | The steps the candidate took, in their own words: "I did..." | "What did you do, specifically? What did you do first?" | "We" all the way through; vague or textbook answers |
| Result | What happened, ideally with numbers, and what they learned | "What was the outcome? How did you know? What would you do differently?" | No result, or a result they cannot explain |
Most of the evidence sits in the Action. Spend most of your follow-up time there.
How to link competencies and STAR
Competencies tell you what to assess. STAR tells you how to collect and judge the evidence. Link them in four steps:
- Choose four to six competencies from the job description, such as Ownership, Collaboration or Customer focus.
- Define each one in observable terms, with a short description of what a score of 1, 3 and 5 looks like.
- Write one or two STAR questions for each competency, opening with "Tell me about a time when...".
- Score each answer on that competency's scale, using the STAR evidence. The strength of the Action and the Result decides the score, not how confident the candidate sounded.
Example scale: Ownership
| Score | What the STAR evidence shows |
|---|---|
| 1: weak | Describes problems as someone else's; no example of acting without being asked |
| 3: good | Gives a clear example of taking responsibility for a problem and seeing it through |
| 5: excellent | Several examples of spotting problems early, acting on their own, and improving the process for others |
A worked example
Competency: Ownership. Question: "Tell me about a time you noticed a problem that was not your responsibility and decided to act on it."
| Weak answer (score 1 to 2) | Strong answer (score 4 to 5) | |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | "In my last job there were always delays." | "Last year, our month-end payroll kept going out two days late." |
| Task | "We needed to fix it." | "It was not my job, but late salaries were hurting trust, so I offered to find the cause." |
| Action | "We had some meetings and improved the process." | "I mapped each step with finance, found that approvals sat with one manager, and proposed a backup approver and a checklist." |
| Result | "Things got better." | "Payroll went out on time for the next six months, and the checklist is still in use. I learned to bring data before proposing a change." |
Both candidates may be pleasant and confident. Only one gives you evidence. Note the key points of each part on the Interview Scorecard, then score against the scale.
When candidates have little experience
STAR questions work best for people with relevant experience. For graduates or career changers, let them draw their examples from study, volunteering or projects, and use situational questions ("What would you do if...") for some competencies. Keep the same scale, so candidates are still compared fairly.
Running the interview
- Welcome and explain the format (5 minutes).
- Core questions with follow-ups (30 to 35 minutes).
- The candidate's questions (10 minutes). Good questions tell you a lot.
- Next steps and timeline (5 minutes).
Keep it professional, not interrogating. Candidates judge your company by how you interview them, and they tell others.
Questions you should not ask
Both countries prohibit discrimination in hiring. Egypt's Labour Law No. 14 of 2025 covers grounds including religion, belief, gender, origin, colour, language, disability and social level. Saudi Arabia's 2025 Labor Law amendments protect job applicants on grounds including gender, age, colour, disability and marital status. Questions on these topics invite a discrimination claim and tell you nothing about the job.
| Topic | Avoid | Ask instead, if relevant |
|---|---|---|
| Age | "How old are you?" | Nothing. Focus on experience and skills. |
| Family | "Are you married? Do you plan to have children?" | "This role needs travel twice a month. Is that workable for you?" |
| Religion | "What is your religion?" | Nothing. It is not relevant to the job. |
| Health and disability | "Do you have any health problems?" | "Can you do the essential tasks of this role, with or without adjustments?" |
| Origin and nationality | "Where are you originally from?" | "Are you legally able to work in this country?" |
Handle candidate data with care
CVs, interview notes and test results are personal data. Saudi Arabia's Personal Data Protection Law and Egypt's Law No. 151 of 2020 both apply to them. Keep notes factual and job-related, share them only with the hiring panel, store them securely, and do not keep them longer than you need. If you use AI tools to screen CVs or analyse interviews, read Using AI in HR Without Losing Trust first; in Saudi Arabia, decisions based entirely on automated processing need explicit consent.
Decide fast and close well
Hold the panel discussion within a day of the last interview, while the evidence is fresh. Good candidates have other options; a slow process loses them. Tell unsuccessful candidates promptly and respectfully. For the chosen candidate, put the offer in writing with our Offer Letter template, then plan the first 90 days with Onboarding That Sticks.
Mistakes to avoid
- Deciding in the first five minutes and spending the rest of the interview confirming it.
- Different questions for different candidates.
- Talking more than the candidate.
- Accepting a "we" answer without asking what the candidate did personally.
- Scoring after the panel discussion instead of before it.
- Hiring for "culture fit" when you mean "like us"; assess the values you wrote down instead.
- Leaving candidates without an answer for weeks.
Frequently asked questions
How many interviewers should we use?
Two or three. One interviewer gives you one opinion; more than three slows the process without adding much.
How many interview rounds are enough?
For most roles, two: a structured interview and a work sample or a second structured interview with the hiring manager. Senior roles may need a third.
Can we still have an informal chat?
Yes, as part of the process, for example a coffee with the team. Just do not let it replace the structured, scored part.
Should we give feedback to rejected candidates?
A short, respectful message is enough. If you give detailed feedback, keep it to job-related points from the scorecard.
Many candidates have rehearsed STAR stories. Does it still work?
Yes. Prepared stories are fine, but details reveal whether they really happened. Probe the Action with two or three follow-ups: who else was involved, what exactly they did first, what went wrong along the way.
What if a candidate has no example for a competency?
Ask for an example from another setting, such as study, volunteering or a previous job, or switch to a situational question. Note it on the scorecard rather than scoring zero automatically.
Start with the scorecard
Download our free Interview Scorecard, add your four to six competencies with their 1, 3 and 5 descriptions, and write two STAR questions for each. That alone will make your next hire fairer and better.
If you would like help designing your interview process or training your managers to interview well, you can work with me directly.
Note: This article is general guidance and not legal advice. Check the rules that apply to your hiring process before you act.
Last updated: 22 November 2026
References
- Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens (2022): Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection, Journal of Applied Psychology
- Criteria Corp: What the new research says about employee selection
- Lockton: Egypt adopts comprehensive new labor law (anti-discrimination in hiring)
- STA Law Firm: Key amendments to Saudi Arabia's Labour Law (2025)
- Clyde & Co: Saudi Arabia issues Implementing Regulations to the PDPL
- CMS: Egypt's PDPL executive regulations issued
Keep reading
Job Descriptions That Attract the Right People, and Help You Hire Them
Write job descriptions that attract the right candidates and help you hire well: the six parts of a strong JD, how to turn it into a job ad, and the legal rules in Egypt and Saudi Arabia.
What a Headhunter Notices in the First 10 Seconds of a CV
A headhunter in Egypt and Saudi Arabia explains what recruiters look at first on a CV, what makes them stop reading, and a simple 10-second test before you apply.
The First People & Culture Hire in a SaaS or AI Startup: What the Role Really Is in Years 1 to 3
What the first People & Culture leader in a SaaS or AI startup should own in years one to three, the profile to hire, and the mistakes founders in Egypt and Saudi Arabia make.
