Handling Poor Performance Fairly: Warnings and Improvement Plans in Egypt and Saudi Arabia
How to handle poor performance fairly in Egypt and Saudi Arabia: tell skill gaps from misconduct, run an improvement plan, and follow the legal rules for warnings.
Most managers wait too long. They hope the problem will fix itself, then lose patience and want the person gone by the end of the month. By then there are no notes, no warnings and no plan, only frustration. That is how a performance problem turns into a legal one.
There is a better order of steps. It is fairer to the employee, it gives them a real chance to improve, and if things still do not work out, it leaves you with a record that holds up. This guide covers that process and the legal rules for warnings in Egypt and Saudi Arabia.
First question: can't or won't?
Before you act, decide what kind of problem you have. The answer decides which route you take.
| Can't (performance) | Won't (conduct) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it looks like | Misses targets, makes repeated errors, works too slowly | Ignores instructions, comes late, breaks a policy |
| Usual causes | Unclear expectations, missing skills, poor tools, wrong role | Choice or attitude |
| Right route | Coaching, then a performance improvement plan | The formal disciplinary process |
| Main document | Improvement plan with targets and support | Written investigation and a written penalty, such as a warning |
Mixing the two is the most common mistake. A warning for missed targets, without a fair investigation, will not stand. And a long coaching plan will not fix someone who simply refuses to follow the rules.
The performance route
Step 1: check the basics
Ask yourself first: Did the person know exactly what was expected? Did they have the tools, access and training? Has the workload or the role changed? A surprising number of "performance problems" are really management problems.
Step 2: have the direct conversation
Meet privately. Describe the gap with specific examples and figures, not labels such as "lazy" or "not committed". Listen to the employee's view. Agree what good looks like and by when. Then send a short email that sums up what you agreed. That email is your first record.
Step 3: put it in an improvement plan
If things do not improve within a few weeks, move to a written plan. Our Performance Improvement Plan template covers what it needs:
- The specific gap, with examples.
- Two to four measurable targets for the plan period.
- The support you will give: training, coaching, tools or a mentor.
- Check-in dates, weekly or every two weeks.
- A plan period of 30 to 90 days, depending on the role.
- What happens at the end: the plan is closed successfully, extended once, or you move to the next step.
Write each check-in down, even in three lines. Use the Quarterly Performance Check-in form if you need a structure.
Step 4: close the plan honestly
If the targets are met, say so clearly and close the plan. Many employees recover fully once expectations are clear and support is real. If they are not met, review the record with HR before you decide anything, because the next step has legal consequences.
The conduct route: warnings and the law
A warning is a disciplinary penalty in both countries, not just a strongly worded email. That means the law decides how you give it.
| Egypt (Law No. 14 of 2025) | Saudi Arabia (Labor Law) | |
|---|---|---|
| Penalties allowed | Article 139: written warning, deduction from basic wage, postponed or reduced annual increment, postponed promotion, a cut in basic wage of up to one increment, demotion by one grade without a pay cut, and dismissal under the law | Article 66: warning, fine, withholding or postponing an allowance for up to a year, postponing promotion for up to a year, suspension without pay, and dismissal in the cases the law sets out |
| Before any penalty | A written, impartial investigation, hearing the worker and their defence | Article 71: written notice of the allegations, questioning, and a record of the defence kept in the file; minor cases can be handled verbally but still recorded |
| Time limits | The penalty must be imposed within 30 days of finishing the investigation | No charge for an offence discovered more than 30 days earlier, and no penalty more than 30 days after the investigation ends (Article 69) |
| Wage deductions | Up to five working days' pay per violation and five days in a month | A fine of up to five days' wage per violation and five days in a month |
| Dismissal | Disciplinary dismissal for gross misconduct needs a labour court ruling | Only in the cases listed in the law, such as Article 80 |
In Saudi Arabia, the employee must be told of the penalty in writing and can object within 15 days. In Egypt, every private establishment with 10 or more workers must now have approved workplace regulations that list the violations and the penalty for each. In both countries, apply only the penalties in your approved internal rules, and only one penalty per violation.
Our Written Warning Letter template follows this structure: the facts, the rule broken, the employee's response, the expected change and what happens if it repeats.
When it does not work out
Sometimes, after a fair plan and real support, the role is still not a fit. Ending the contract is then a legal decision, so take advice on the specific case. The broad rules:
- Egypt: inefficiency can be a lawful ground for ending an indefinite contract, but only after following your internal procedures. If a contract is ended without a legitimate reason, the minimum compensation is two months' salary for each year of service.
- Saudi Arabia: poor performance is not one of the Article 80 grounds for dismissal without notice. If a contract is ended without a valid reason, the employee can claim compensation under Article 77, which for an indefinite contract is 15 days' wage per year of service, with a minimum of two months' wage.
- In both countries: your notes, check-ins, improvement plan and any warnings are the evidence. Without them, a performance-based exit is very hard to defend.
A mutual separation agreement, with a fair package and a respectful exit, is often better for both sides than a dispute.
Mistakes to avoid
- Raising the problem for the first time in the annual review.
- Using a warning for missed targets instead of a plan with support.
- Giving a "warning" without the investigation the law requires.
- Letting the 30-day limits pass, then trying to act months later.
- Writing vague labels instead of facts, dates and examples.
- Deducting pay or blocking an increment outside your approved internal rules.
Frequently asked questions
Is an improvement plan a disciplinary penalty?
No. It is not on the list of penalties in either country. It is a support tool with clear targets, so keep it separate from warnings and do not attach a pay cut to it.
How long should an improvement plan last?
Usually 30 to 90 days. Shorter for clear, measurable roles such as sales; longer where results take time to show. Extend once at most.
Can I give a verbal warning?
In Saudi Arabia, minor cases can be handled verbally, but the questioning must still be recorded in writing. In Egypt, the warning on the penalty list is a written warning. Either way, keep a written record.
Can I deduct salary because results are poor?
Wage deductions are disciplinary penalties for violations. They need the investigation, the time limits and the caps above. Do not use them to punish low results; use an improvement plan instead.
Fair is also effective
A clear conversation, a written plan and honest support solve most performance problems. When they do not, the same record protects you. Build the habit into your regular cycle with A Simple Performance Review System, and start new hires on the right foot with Probation Done Right. For the wider legal picture in Egypt, see Egypt's New Labour Law checklist.
If you would like help with a difficult case, your workplace regulations or manager training, you can work with me directly.
Note: This article is general guidance and not legal advice. Before imposing a penalty or ending a contract, take advice on your specific case.
Last updated: 19 November 2026
References
- Egypt Labour Law No. 14 of 2025 (official text, Arabic)
- Sada El Balad: disciplinary penalties under Egypt's new Labour Law, Articles 139-140 (Arabic)
- Enterprise: workplace regulations for private establishments with 10 or more workers (Egypt, 2026)
- Legalmondo: Termination of employment contracts in Egypt (Law 14/2025)
- Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development (Saudi Arabia): disciplinary penalties, Articles 66-72
- HD Law Firm: Saudi Labor Law termination by the employer and Article 77
اقرأ أيضًا
Probation Done Right: A Practical Guide for Egypt and Saudi Arabia
Probation rules in Egypt and Saudi Arabia side by side, plus a simple review process, a free probation review form and the mistakes that cost employers.
Saudi End-of-Service Award Explained, with Worked Examples
How the end-of-service award is calculated under the Saudi Labor Law: the formula, which wage to use, resignation shares, worked examples and payment deadlines.
Egypt's New Labour Law (Law 14 of 2025): A Checklist for Employers
A practical 10-point checklist for employers in Egypt under Labour Law No. 14 of 2025: contracts, probation, leave, the 3% increment, remote work and termination.
